How Falling Behind Can Get You Ahead
📹 15 minutes TEDx talk from Manchester 2020 How falling behind can get you ahead some highlights:
- “Jack of all trades, master of none,” the saying goes. But it is culturally telling that we have chopped off the ending: “…but oftentimes better than master of one.”
- In a society hyperfocused on headstarts, we are told to choose our paths early, focus narrowly, and start racking up our 10,000 hours of deliberate practice. But a mountain of research shows that, among people who end up fulfilled and successful, early specialization is the exception, not the rule.
- Winding paths and mental meandering can be sources of power, not disadvantages, but we rarely hear those stories. David is trying to change this.
Specialising may not be such a great thing and references an interesting theory Kind and Wicked Learning environments.
- Good explanation here: https://www.driverlesscrocodile.com/books-and-recommendations/david-epstein-on-kind-and-wicked-learning-environments/ from the speaker of the ted talk
- Actual paper from Robert Hogarth et al The two settings of kind and wicked learning environments
Kind Learning environments
- Kind give lots of feedback as you progress which aid deliberate learning
- The rule of the system don’t change either so what it is today is the same tomorrow
- Golf and chess are such environments
Wicked learning environments
- Mixed levels of feedback as you progress
- Rules of the system keep changing
- I think software engineering maybe a wicked environment
- But need to do more research
The biases called out in the paper could be really helpful when thinking about decision making that affect learning in these environments. I’m also certain I’ve been influenced by survivorship, censorship, selection and the ‘hot stove’ biases.
Leave a Reply
Want to join the discussion?Feel free to contribute!